Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marjorie J. Birch's avatar

The Countess is the broken heart beneath all the foolery; this is what makes "The Marriage of Figaro" the masterpiece it is. That, and its declaration that broken hearts can be mended as well.

I do not understand the all-American aversion to opera. If you think about it, country music sings about the same kind of thing -- broken hearts, betrayal. And some of the country/western ladies wear outfits as bodacious as you'll find in opera.

For years, I listened to opera in the car. I'd pick a straight road, turn the sound up and listen to singers sing loud about secret feelings. At the apartment, if I played "Ode to Joy" at a volume where I could actually hear it, the pounding on the ceiling would commence. I once attempted to listen to the Sextet from "Lucia di Lammermoor" at one of my office jobs, as sublime a piece of music as you'll ever hear -- and you would have thought that I was sticking red hot needles into my coworkers. "Ew! Ew! NOT OPERAAAAAAAAA...." Being raised to be considerate (Translation: doormat) I turned it off. That was the early 1980s and Mister Keillor, I AM STILL MAD. The rage of the liberal who politely listens to sugarpop music on her coworker's radio stations ... I TOLERATE YOUR CRAP, WHY CAN'T YOU TOLERATE DONIZETTI for ten minutes out of your precious lives????"

(deep breath.)

Is it all that bawling, naked emotion that makes people curl up in a knot with their fists pressed against their ears?

I don't know. I'm just grateful for the technology that lets me listen to the music without someone whining in the background.

And I must attend a Met performance before I die or it dies.

Thanks, Mister Keillor, for your words.

Expand full comment
M. Helen Tintes's avatar

Thank you so much…we Opera singers and teachers of the next generation really appreciate this!

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts