A fine night in York, Pennsylvania
The Column: 09.23.24
I walked into the Baltimore airport at 7:15 Friday morning, checked a bag, and walked to the end of the endless Boarding line, which moved swiftly back and forth between the straps, was sniffed by a dog, photographed by a TSA lady, went through the hypermagnetic sonar encephaloscanner, was declared sane, and got to a café near my gate and my coffee was poured at 7:40. A good beginning to a day.
The night before I had done my solo show at the Strand Theatre in York, PA. The stage looked big and empty and I worried that the audience would expect me to dance or do cartwheels so I did the show from the house, walking up and down the aisles, which people seemed to like. I start off by singing a prayer, an Episcopal rouser, an anti-thong song, a hymn to perseverance (“So do your work, keep going straight ahead, and you can be a genius after you are dead”), an homage to summer and a descriptive song about the journey of sperm in search of a willing egg, all from memory while ambulating in close proximity to the customers and shaking a few hands. At first I was blinded by the spotlight and had to tread carefully lest I trip and land in someone’s lap but I ascended about one-third of the way back and then I could see people so I did the show from there — 400 people could see me and for the 200 down front it was like radio.
I told them that Pennsylvania is in a tough spot, as a big swing state, and on Election Night when the state is called, the side it votes for will figure, “Well of course, but why such a narrow margin?” and the other side will despise them and never buy another Hershey’s bar ever. I announced that I was a Kamalaist because I’m tired of my gender being held responsible for leadership, it’s time for women to take their turn. This harmless joke did not land all that well, like the crowd was maybe one-third Trumpian, maybe more, and so I veered off in a patriotic direction — “We’re all Americans and we have more in common than we have to argue about” (a dubious assertion, I know plenty of Americans who, if I were hitchhiking and they picked me up, I’d ask to be let out) and I hummed a note and sang “My country, ’tis of thee” and they were all with me and it was stunningly beautiful. I don’t exaggerate. They sang softly in four-part harmony. So we did “God Bless America” and “Shenandoah” and “My Girl” and “How Great Thou Art,” which most stand-up comics wouldn’t include but I’m 82 and get to make my own rules and the crowd was touched by their own singing.
And then I went into some comical stem-winding about the beauties of old age, one being that your career is over, your ambition is exhausted, and now you get to have fun, which I proceeded to do at length, and we sang the Beatles’ “In My Life” as I exited out through the lobby.
After the show I stood out on the curb and talked to people, not about politics, though a man did point out that York had briefly, during the Revolution, been General Washington’s HQ when the Brits were in Philly and so was the de facto nation’s capital. Okay, then. But I did wonder how these good people could pass up a smart public-spirited well-spoken woman who is up on the issues for an angry real-estate tycoon who has adopted the style of a professional wrestler and who believes that an outrageous lie repeated repeatedly thereby becomes passable. The man is a living satire of male ego and blather. He is also 78 and if you read transcripts of his speeches, you think his family needs to think about conservatorship. The beloved country has a month in which to come to its senses. There is, among young men, a taste for outright fascism that we never had noticed before. Thank you, Taylor Swift. Now where is Laura Bush? Nikki Haley, time to change your mind and save your soul.
It’s not too early to start making plans for 2025. Start the year off right by attending a live performance of Garrison Keillor Tonight!
CLICK HERE to buy tickets today! Scroll down to see the complete list of upcoming shows.
It's taking some good chutzpah to stand in front of, or among, a crowd of tRumpers and declare that you're a Kamalist, Mr. Keillor. This fellow American salutes you for it! It is beyond belief, beyond understanding, what is happening in this country. Knowing what we know, seeing what we see, hearing what we hear, if that hideous monstrosity wins (in any legitimate sense), then we surely have to admit that this country is not the country we thought it was. As beautiful as group singing, spontaneous a capella singing, is, that is temporary balm, isn't it, and can't compensate for the fact - as you observed - that a large proportion of that audience would cheer and clap for the Con-artist Who Would Be King and sing the same songs under the "protection" of the fascist. His most recent speech, the "I Am Your Protector" bilge directed at women, supposedly, is chilling, horrific, creepy, disturbing and infuriating. Seeing him deliver it and seeing people there with their young children listening to it just repulsive.
It's difficult enough to realize that he is running; it is just about unbearable to hear the near-constant refrain of what the polls "say" - and even when Harris leads by some amount, it is always still close. It is just unbelievable!
I recommend to you again, on the blessed YouTube, The Marsh Family and their delightful rendition of "Kamala, Give Us Hope." Try that with your next group singing audience and see how warm and fuzzy the audience singers are. Or try Leonard Cohen singing "Democracy Is Coming to the U.S.A."
This is so absolutely beautiful. I can hear the show as you describe it. And I too, wonder how a crowd who would choose to pay for tickets, brave COVID and all other crowd-opportunistic autumn illnesses, get a babysitter, wear ill- fitting yet nice looking footwear …. AND sing heart-tugging songs together IN HARMONY - meaning NOT the same notes, but notes which blend and meld and weave together as one - a melting pot, you might say …. How does THAT crowd not believe that this election is genuinely about so much more than what political party you like. As I see it, political party has very little to do with this specific election. This election is about patriotism. About that which brings us all together. About a shared vision of strangers with such an overwhelming amount of similarities that together, they can join in on Shenandoah … and leave that theater with their hearts still singing.
We need a President and Vice President who know the words to Shenandoah. And there is a ticket available. Please America. Let us sing together. It has never been more important.