Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Leslie Fischgrund's avatar

You do realize that Gettysburg was a Union victory, right? And it marked the beginning of the downfall of the Confederacy?

Granted, I am over 60 now, but Gettysburg has greatly updated their programs and exhibits. Did you know that the lead from the bullets used during the battle killed almost every tree on the battlefield? How both armies pulled out and left the villagers of Gettysburg to deal with the dead...humans, animals, etc....in a day before there really was heavy equipment to do the excavation.

More than anything, I think Gettysburg illustrates the tremendous cost of war as does Antietam.

I live near New Market, Virginia. The boys from Virginia Military Institute (VMI) strode up the road to meet their destiny and join the Great War. It rained. The plowed fields were so muddy that it sucked the shoes and boots off the soldiers as they worked their way across the field in withering fire. I believe eight of those boys (they were 15 and 16) died; one lingered for over a week. The family on whose farm a lot of the battle was fought crouched in their basement during the barrage of artillery.

As Americans, that was the last war fought on American soil. We have no connection with the suffering in Ukraine and little connection with that in the Middle East. The battlefield parks explain some of that.

And you can ride a bicycle through them, walk them, picnic on them. To eliminate them would be to erase part of our history.

Expand full comment
Rick Friedman's avatar

One cannot help growing older but turning into a grumpy, old man, Garrison, remains your option.

Were it not for the Union soldiers from your home state of Minnesota on Cemetery Ridge on July 2, 1863, Lee might well have turned his eventual defeat into victory at Gettysburg and gone on to win the war. Have you no respect for the sacrifices made by others that have enabled people like you and me to live in this beautiful country?

Please refrain from future cynical, self-absorbed columns on the possibilities of desecrating Arlington National Cemetery and Omaha Beach. To paraphrase Joseph Welch, "Let us not assassinate these lads further, Garrison, you have done enough. Have you no sense of decency?"

Expand full comment
58 more comments...

No posts