Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dana's avatar

I don't consider myself well versed on this subject, but when those of us who are not trans or non-binary are asked to supply our pronouns, I think we should simply do so. Just be ready with "he/him/his" or "she/her/hers." I don't know if this will become a universal convention in human society or become outmoded and unnecessary. Right now, understanding the pronoun issue, and certainly not ridiculing people or institutions over it, is a small and easy way to express solidarity with or at least non-hostility to communities that are under attack by "leaders" like Ron DeSantis, Greg Abbott and many others.

We are talking about minorities who are being targeted and harassed by politicians seeking political gain. These attacks can and do lead to open hostility and violence. I see nothing admirable in a college professor who refuses to follow his employer's policy in this regard. It shouldn't be a mental stretch for a teacher of all people to grasp the reasons for such a policy.

I am still sometimes confused by the use of them/their/theirs as a person's pronouns, because I think of these as plurals. But I'm fully prepared to get used to it should I come into regular contact with someone whose pronouns are they/them/theirs. As the previous sentence shows, the use of plural pronouns in the singular is not at all unprecedented in the English language. It goes back centuries, so I know I'll manage.

I just did a quick Google search on communities that announce their pronouns. This is the first hit that came up; it raises some points that I had never considered: https://lgbtqia.ucdavis.edu/educated/pronouns-inclusive-language

Expand full comment
Jim Crissman's avatar

Being a Unitarian, I hear the pronoun nonsense every Sunday that I attend. Our male and married minister announces that he's a he/him/his. Please make it stop. I haven't yet been asked to supply my pronouns, but I'm thinking, "Hey, you!" Okay, so hey isn't a pronoun, but you need to get my attention since noise and years have robbed my ears of hair cells and driven me into my head. I used to study in the grill in my dorm at Michigan State, seems I needed cacophony to concentrate against. Perhaps your barbarian neighbors could inspire you to lock your mind onto physics 201 and understand what a beam of light you are for the rest of us.

Expand full comment
61 more comments...

No posts